Good thread Pale it is very thought provoking. I remember many years ago a person we all knew who was labeled a apostate ask for reinstatement. This was in the late 1990's and it was very unusual for someone to be df for apostacy and he was reinstated. This stigma of once being a apostate stuck with him even years after he was reinstated. If I remember correctly the wt. rules were he could never be appointed as a Ms or elder again and used very limited on any minor responsibility's. Even though he repented there was a invisible wall built up around him for life. Just for not agreeing with some of the teachings of the wt.
At the time I was in total agreement with this arrangement but now I can see how this stigma could have a very detrimental emotional effect on someone. As a born-in this was a very normal thinking for me but now I see it contrary to normal human emotions. Cults like the wt. seem to know how to control people. Still Totally ADD